Home page > Food and Agriculture > Food and Nutrition > Industry to challenge EU food (...)

UK industry has challenged the Food Supplements Directive 2002/46/EC before the European Court of Justice (ECJ).

On Friday 30th January 2004, the UK Health Food Manufacturers Association, together with the UK National Association of Health Stores, and with support from UK Consumers for Health Choice and the Alliance for Natural Health [1], won a legal ruling from the High Court in London that allowed them to take a challenge to the legality and proportionality of the Food Supplements Directive to the ECJ in Luxembourg.

The European Commission wants to tighten up the rules on food supplements from August 2005. Under the new rules, only vitamins and minerals on an approved list, the so-called "Positive List", can be used in supplements. There will also be restrictions on the upper limits of vitamin doses.

The governments of UK, Greece and Portugal, together with the EU Commission, Council and Parliament have all made submissions to the ECJ in opposition to the British manufacturer’s and retailer’s case.

The verdict is judged largely on written evidence and should be delivered a few months after the Hearing, which will take place from Tuesday, 25th January 2005 to Monday, 31st January 2005. The judgement is expected to be delivered before the judicial summer vacation (August).

In this regard, the industry has announced to be monitoring the process to ensure that judgement is delivered before the "Positive Lists" come into effect from 1st August 2005.

Footnotes

[1] A European wide organisation that represents manufacturers, formulators, distributors and suppliers amongst other stakeholders

Last modified on February 1 2005.

Your feedback is valuable to us!

Was this article interesting and relevant for you? Do you have any comments?

7 Forum messages

Our readers have published these comments:

6 December 2004 12:45

> Industry to challenge EU food suplements directive

You say that the UK govt opposes the directive, yet how is it that they ratified the directive in the house of commons this July 2004. Where would one read about the specifics of the EU directive ?

Reply to this message

7 December 2004 00:50

Dear reader,

Thank you for your contribution.

Let me clarify that this article does not mention the UK goverment.

It’s the UK industry who opposes the directive (UK Health Food Manufacturers Association and UK National Association of Health Stores).

You can read the directive by clicking on the article’s sentence "Food Supplements Directive 2002/46/EC" or by copying and pasting the following link into your web browser:

http://europa.eu.int/smartapi/cgi/sga_doc?smartapi!celexapi!prod!CELEXnumdoc&lg=EN&numdoc=32002L0046&model=guichett

Kind regards.

Reply to this message

4 January 2005 23:01

With respect, your article did say "The UK government had opposed the move."

Did they oppose the directive or the challenge to the directive?

Reply to this message

6 January 2005 01:39, by Lara Garrido-Herrero, EPHA Staff (Admin)

Dear reader,

Once again, thank you very much for your input that helps us updating our articles.

I hope that with the last corrections your need for accurate information is fulfilled.

Do not hesitate contacting us otherwise.

Regards.

Reply to this message

31 January 2005 15:13, by Dian Kjærgaard

> Industry to challenge EU food suplements directive

Dear People,

A very informative article. But why don’t you mention the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH) as another key actor in the court challenges?

Please answer!

Reply to this message

1 February 2005 09:28, by Lara Garrido-Herrero, EPHA Staff (Admin)

Thank you very much for your comment.

We have added the name of the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH) to the article.

Regards.

Reply to this message

21 August 2005 04:34, by b. reiter

> Industry to challenge EU food suplements directive

Your site is outdated. Please re-write your site to inform about the passage of the EU laws effective August 2005 and what this means...we desperately need this info and a new plan of action against the EU directive!! Thanks B Reiter

See online : Industry to Challenge EU directive

Reply to this message